Details to read differently
The book is warm and practical, but medicine has moved on in places, a few narrations are weak, and some rulings need care. Here they are, chapter by chapter.
Chapter 1
Jaundice and vaccines
The book treats jaundice as a concern only if it lasts beyond two weeks. Current guidance adds that yellowing in the first 24 hours, very pale stools, or a baby who is sleepy and feeding poorly needs a doctor the same day. The vaccine table in the book is one schedule from its time; follow your own country’s.
See our pageChapter 2
The adhan in the baby’s ear
The report of Abu Rafi‘ behind this practice (Abu Dawud and at-Tirmidhi) is graded hasan by some scholars and weak by others. Most schools still count the practice recommended, and little Amanah shows its grading.
See our pageChapter 2
Not breaking the ‘aqiqah’s bones
The book makes this a point to observe. The report behind it is weak, and it is not a condition of the ‘aqiqah.
See our pageChapter 2
Who holds circumcision obligatory
The book counts Imam Malik among those who hold male circumcision obligatory. That is the Shafi‘i and Hanbali position; the Maliki and Hanafi schools count it a confirmed sunnah. Little Amanah follows the view that it is required.
See our pageChapter 2
Female circumcision
The book presents this briefly as a matter of disagreement. The hadith it quotes about “the two circumcised parts” concerns when ghusl becomes due, and does not settle the ruling. Scholars and doctors differ, and the World Health Organization advises against any cutting of girls for non-medical reasons. Ask a scholar you trust and a female doctor.
Chapter 3
Intimacy after the birth
The book says to wait at least forty days. In fiqh the ruling follows the postnatal bleeding (nifas): it lasts at most forty days and ends sooner if the bleeding stops and ghusl is made, and only intercourse is prohibited during it. The doctor’s check at around six weeks is separate, medical advice.
See our pageChapter 3
Diet advice after the birth
The food-combining rules the book takes from a popular diet book have no good evidence behind them, and cutting out all fats isn’t advised, least of all while breastfeeding. Its warning about girdles and corsets is sound.
See our pageChapter 3
Low mood after the birth
The book tells mothers to hurry to fight these feelings. Postnatal depression is an illness, not a failing, and it is treatable. If low mood or anxiety lasts more than two weeks, or you have thoughts of harming yourself or the baby, speak to a doctor or midwife straight away.
See our pageChapter 4
Feeding details that have changed
Expressed milk now keeps for up to about four days in a fridge at 4°C or colder and around six months in a freezer, longer than the book’s 24 hours and three months. Throw away formula left after a feed rather than keeping it, and use a faster-flow teat instead of widening the hole with a needle. Sore or cracked nipples usually call for help with the latch rather than a break of several days, and a new pregnancy isn’t in itself a reason to stop at five months: ask your doctor.
See our pageChapter 5
Fever in babies
The book uses 37.8°C as the line and suggests a lukewarm bath. Current UK advice: a baby under three months with a temperature of 38°C or more needs a doctor straight away, and sponging with water is no longer recommended. Never give a child under sixteen aspirin (the book says under twelve), and don’t give a crying baby diluted juice: under one year, milk is the drink.
See our pageChapter 6
Safe sleep
Newborns usually sleep about 14 to 17 hours a day, rather than the book’s 16 to 20. The book leaves sharing a bed up to the mother; current advice is a cot of their own in the parents’ room for at least six months, and never sharing a bed or sofa after alcohol, sedating medicine or smoking. Its two passages on leaving a baby to cry disagree; we follow the one that tells you to respond.
See our pageChapter 7
When to start solids
The book starts between four and six months, begins with rice, and delays wheat, egg white and nuts. The WHO and NHS now advise starting at around six months and introducing common allergens such as egg, wheat and peanut (smooth, never whole) one at a time from then, rather than later. Juice isn’t needed before one; offer water in a cup.
See our pageChapter 8
Dummies and teething gels
The book calls dummies harmful. Current advice notes that a dummy at sleep time may lower the risk of sudden infant death, if it is weaned by about a year. Many teething gels are not meant for babies, so ask a pharmacist, and brush the first teeth with a smear of fluoride toothpaste.
See our pageChapter 11
Two languages
The book lists bilingualism among the causes of late talking. Research doesn’t support this: children raised with two languages reach their milestones on the usual timeline. Keep speaking your home language.
See our pageChapter 12
Everyday greetings
The book tells parents to stop children saying “good morning” or “bye-bye”. The salam is the Sunnah greeting and comes first, but many scholars allow ordinary polite words alongside it, so long as they don’t replace it.
See our pageChapter 12
Weak narrations
A few reports in this chapter have weak chains: “raise your children on three things”, the story of al-Hasan and al-Husayn lost on a mountain with a snake, and “the best house is one with an orphan treated well”. Kindness to orphans rests on sound hadith all the same, such as “I and the one who cares for an orphan will be like this in Paradise” (al-Bukhari).
See our pageChapter 13
Screens and smacking
The book allows one or two hours of television a day; the WHO advises no screens before two and no more than an hour a day from two to four. We leave out the book’s quotation of a professor who argues for smacking by comparing children with wives. The author herself sides with the specialists who reject it, and ‘A’ishah reported that the Prophet ﷺ never struck a woman or a servant (Muslim).
See our pageChapter 13
A smoking figure
The WHO estimate of around 600,000 deaths a year from second-hand smoke counts all ages, not only children as the book says; a little over a quarter of those deaths are children.
Chapter 15
First aid that has changed
Cool a burn under cool running water for 20 minutes (the book says 10 to 15). Clean small wounds with running water rather than surgical spirit. Don’t tie a band above a snake bite: keep the limb still and get help. If a child has a prescribed adrenaline auto-injector, use it at once in a severe reaction and call an ambulance.
See our page